Adventures in chatbusting — OpenAI and Common Sense Media partner to protect teens from AI harms and misuse Site gave ChatGPT 3 stars and 48% privacy score: “Best used for creativity, not facts.”
Benj Edwards – Jan 29, 2024 11:12 pm UTC EnlargeGetty Images reader comments 23
On Monday, OpenAI announced a partnership with the nonprofit Common Sense Media to create AI guidelines and educational materials targeted at parents, educators, and teens. It includes the curation of family-friendly GPTs in OpenAI’s GPT store. The collaboration aims to address concerns about the impacts of AI on children and teenagers. Further ReadingChatGPT is one year old. Heres how it changed the tech world.
Known for its reviews of films and TV shows aimed at parents seeking appropriate media for their kids to watch, Common Sense Media recently branched out into AI and has been reviewing AI assistants on its site.
“AI isnt going anywhere, so its important that we help kids understand how to use it responsibly,” Common Sense Media wrote on X. “Thats why weve partnered with @OpenAI to help teens and families safely harness the potential of AI.”
OpenAI CEO Sam Altman and Common Sense Media CEO James Steyer announced the partnership onstage in San Francisco at the Common Sense Summit for America’s Kids and Families, an event that was well-covered by media members on the social media site X.
For his part, Altman offered a canned statement in the press release, saying, “AI offers incredible benefits for families and teens, and our partnership with Common Sense will further strengthen our safety work, ensuring that families and teens can use our tools with confidence.” Further ReadingOpenAIs GPT Store lets ChatGPT users discover popular user-made chatbot roles
The announcement feels slightly non-specific in the official news release, with Steyer offering, “Our guides and curation will be designed to educate families and educators about safe, responsible use of ChatGPT, so that we can collectively avoid any unintended consequences of this emerging technology.” Advertisement
The partnership seems aimed mostly at bringing a patina of family-friendliness to OpenAI’s GPT store, with the most solid reveal being the aforementioned fact that Common Sense media will help with the “curation of family-friendly GPTs in the GPT Store based on Common Sense ratings and standards.” Common Sense AI reviews
As mentioned above, Common Sense Media began reviewing AI assistants on its site late last year. This puts Common Sense Media in an interesting position with potential conflicts of interest regarding the new partnership with OpenAI. However, it doesn’t seem to be offering any favoritism to OpenAI so far. Further ReadingRound 2: We test the new Gemini-powered Bard against ChatGPT
For example, Common Sense Media’s review of ChatGPT calls the AI assistant “A powerful, at times risky chatbot for people 13+ that is best used for creativity, not facts.” It labels ChatGPT as being suitable for ages 13 and up (which is in OpenAI’s Terms of Service) and gives the OpenAI assistant three out of five stars. ChatGPT also scores a 48 percent privacy rating (which is oddly shown as 55 percent on another page that goes into privacy details). The review we cited was last updated on October 13, 2023, as of this writing.
For reference, Google Bard gets a three-star overall rating and a 75 percent privacy rating in its Common Sense Media review. Stable Diffusion, the image synthesis model, nets a one-star rating with the description, “Powerful image generator can unleash creativity, but is wildly unsafe and perpetuates harm.” OpenAI’s DALL-E gets two stars and a 48 percent privacy rating.
The information that Common Sense Media includes about each AI model appears relatively accurate and detailed (and the organization cited an Ars Technica article as a reference in one explanation), so they feel fair, even in the face of the OpenAI partnership. Given the low scores, it seems that most AI models aren’t off to a great start, but that may change. It’s still early days in generative AI. reader comments 23 Benj Edwards Benj Edwards is an AI and Machine Learning Reporter for Ars Technica. In his free time, he writes and records music, collects vintage computers, and enjoys nature. He lives in Raleigh, NC. Advertisement Channel Ars Technica ← Previous story Next story → Related Stories Today on Ars
